Three 'Aha' Moments: A Detective Approach Fixed My Bible Study

It is incredibly easy to feel overwhelmed and confused when trying to read the Bible on your own. That is exactly where I found myself until I picked up a book by J. Warner Wallace called Cold-Case Christianity. His perspective completely changed my approach: I decided to study the Bible as a detective. I realized that if I wanted to understand this important book in history, I couldn't just skim the surface—I had to look for the evidence and decode the language of the original witnesses.

Without historical and contextual knowledge, the text can be confusing. But when you approach it like an investigator, you begin to see that the Bible isn't a collection of disconnected books; it’s a cohesive story. Each book contains pieces of a bigger picture, revealing God’s progressive revelation in His perfect timing. By collecting the evidence and analyzing how it all fits together, the pieces finally start falling into place.

Solving the Puzzle: My Journey to Seeing the Big Picture

As I shared in my first post on two-way prayer, I surrendered my studies to the Holy Spirit’s guidance. Because God promised to guide me, I had to learn to study differently. The most transformative things He led me to discover were the Bible's covenants (the changing agreements God made with humanity), chronology (the historical timeline of when events actually happened), and figures of speech (the cultural idioms and symbolic language of the original writers). These three "Aha" moments completely changed how I collected and analyzed the evidence.

• My first Aha moment: My understanding of the "End Times" (the Bible’s prophecies about the future) used to be a terrifying, looming shadow. I had only ever heard of Futurism—the common view that a scary global tribulation and rapture could happen at any moment. Then, a friend sent me a video about an interpretation called Partial Preterism. I discovered this simply means that many of those scary prophecies were actually historical events that were already fulfilled in the first century. It didn’t just offer a different timeline; it offered an incredible level of peace. I was shocked! I realized that most churches only teach their specific view, which is why I had never heard of other interpretations. This new perspective made so much sense and ignited my determination to dig deeper into the scriptures and explore different views.

• My second Aha moment came when I realized I was trying to follow rules from an old 'contract' (the Mosaic Covenant) that had been fulfilled and replaced by a New Covenant. Learning how these divine agreements were made and functioned was like finding the instruction manual for the whole Bible. Each covenant described in the scriptures was unique and played a specific, beautiful role in God’s plan for mankind as it was revealed and fulfilled over time.

• My third Aha moment happened when I came across the book “Figures of Speech used in the Bible” by E.W. Bullinger. I used to think 'literal' was always better. But I quickly learned that just knowing a literal translation of the words was not sufficient and could be very misleading. Learning the idioms and expressions of that time in history was like learning to speak their language. Even If I did not know Hebrew or Greek, this understanding of these figures of speech used throughout the Bible opened up a way of overcoming that barrier with greater clarity. One example of a figure of speech with a verse that had troubled me was Exodus 9:12 “But the Lord hardened Pharaoh’s heart…”. Did God purposefully harden his heart? If so, that meant God interfered in the Pharaoh’s free will. I learned through the figures of speech that it meant God “allowed” the Pharaoh’s heart to be hardened not that He purposely hardened it. That was a big difference! Understanding this figure of speech didn't just solve a linguistic puzzle; it restored my view of God's character. I realized He wasn't a puppet master forcing people to act, but a patient Creator working within human choices. I discovered many more differences like this that changed the interpretation drastically for many passages in the Bible.

Cultural and Historical Context

Understanding the cultural and historical context was also extremely important. Although the Bible was not written directly to us in our modern world it was written for us as well.

To understand the truth, we must ask:

• What was the intention and meaning of the author?

• What would this have meant to the original intended reader?

Once we have this understanding then we need to discern what still applies to us today by putting all the pieces together. What are the timeless truths or principles? Using all these tools, I dived into many doctrines to try and understand what the Bible itself had to say about many topics. I discovered many different interpretations and came to change quite a few of my views and perspectives on foundational doctrines I had been previously taught. The most important thing for me was to discern what was God’s Truth, it did not matter to me if what I had been previously taught was wrong, I just wanted to know the truth and not continue in error. Every day I asked the Holy Spirit to reveal His truth in my studies. I listened to many sermons, watched numerous videos, read many books and articles, and collected many different Bible translations. I especially valued an interlinear of the New Testament that helped me see the Greek words and definitions for each verse.

2 Timothy 3:16 states: “All scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting, and training in righteousness”. How could this be effective if we were misinterpreting what it said through our ignorance and misunderstanding of figures of speech, covenants and cultural historical context? The “Candid Conversations about Christianity” course contains my exhaustive notes I took on my in-depth six-year study journey. I did all this leg work that you can now benefit from in this all-in-one type of course. Having a resource like this would have been very helpful when I was searching for answers.

Trying to understand all the different views and their supporting arguments was much easier to navigate with this acquired knowledge. As I considered all the different views, this approach guided me in choosing a view to hold to that I felt had the best evidence to support it.

Keep an Open Mind

I am still pondering and learning more every day, remaining open to new evidence or views that may change my perspective. Had I not been open to hearing and considering a different view I would have never grown in a better understanding of the Bible and people’s different perspectives. I had heard church leaders often warn us to be wary of false teachers. While we should always be careful, I discovered that if you have a solid base of evidence and understanding—like a detective with a clear case file—this warning should not discourage or scare you. How do we discern? By holding every teaching up to the light of the whole Bible—putting the puzzle pieces together to see if they actually fit the character of Christ. It will either strengthen your position or show you the error in yours. The most important advice I can offer is to pray to God for wisdom and guidance to reveal His truth when you are in doubt and keep an open mind.

Ready to dig deeper? Check out Lessons Two and Three of my course, "Candid Conversations about Christianity," where I provide the exact tools, charts, and evidence I used during my six-year journey to find the truth.

★ Key Takeaways: Three “Aha” Moments

• The Power of Perspective: Moving from a "Futurist" only view to exploring other interpretations—like Partial Preterism—revealed that many churches only teach one perspective. True growth comes from being open to different views and weighing the evidence for yourself.

• Covenants are the Glue: The Bible is not a random collection of stories, but a structured narrative held together by Covenants. Understanding how God’s plan was revealed "bit-by-bit" through these agreements is essential for seeing the "big picture".

• Language is the Key: Reading the Bible literally can be misleading. By learning "Figures of Speech" and ancient idioms, you can resolve troubling passages—like God "hardening" Pharaoh’s heart—and discover a much more consistent and loving God.

If you would like to take a deeper look into the biblical tools, charts, and evidence I used in my research, I invite you to explore the Candid Conversations about Christianity course. These tools are just the tip of the iceberg, and if you’d like to dive into these 'Aha' moments with others, you can also see our Small Group Guide section.

I’d love to hear about your own journey. Have you had any “Aha” moments that transformed how you study the Bible? Whether you have a comment, a question, or a story you’d like to share, please feel free to reach out through our Contact Us page.

© 2026. All rights reserved.